1、 E %5 Zom= 41:E paE?c1N ? f /,E ? 5 ,E, 4 -S E L= ?E p?ZB3 gbYVd9u E v % E pG ,sBqa qafq E1V ,E2S , V?C,V E M,5 E , 1 L C?ZZ_v,SEv1 9 93 M; Zo:u Iv,uEv20 01 M2 ; K ev in OnBr ien 16r720 M Ll,E B bql7j5 E ,Q4 “5:E v ? ? LCawE p?Z ? T?E p?Z YV I “o|?|YV1 ,E2 S ,B5 E Ll?Zmbt ?Z U,S E Ll5X;CbNV,SEA U bW
2、 la?ZE p( ? b E ?l U SE p?Z+ y , 9 V ? E %E fb5) , oElp d,7 BE IbS5 E p5) , S, E E bSE Ll awE p5, $ 1, %4bql8j“ 8TZ T, E 9 Byb SEE p5 X I h Y f,q *t , a , E p?ZbG Ll, v85, B E p?Z b o pbv8q HW bc 1 1uK Evu E v,#T;a sE2wqbt B ?VS B , LlZb 5 E Ll?Z,1 _:B,E2 E ? ,E5,# 7 E 4 a 7 PopS;=,5 E %z, BH , g B
3、Ba .B ; , a5 8qY %, TBR a1 pb _4|s 8q b, QY N1 p, cKE ?b“1 ,E ? f /,E aBEB5b =da E aH#+q , B?S 5, ) “bBaE# Ll) BE p5 E Ll -, 5 A AEq16rq17rq18rq19rR a n d a ll Pe er e n bo o m , Ch iaanaL o n g Md r eh T o=a rd R u le o f L a w , Ca m br idge U n iv e r sity Pr e ss , 2 0 02 , eha p . 7 (p . 298ff.
4、 ) a n d eh ap . 9 (p . 4 20 ff. ) ; Be nja rn in I iebm a n , Chin anaCo u r t s : R o s tr ie te d R efo r m ? , Chin a Q u a r te rly (2 0 0 7) . Zo:u sS:B: E Ll N(1 990B20 00)v,uvE p v4 2 ,E p2 00 2 MbK) ,nT ho m a s K ello g g ,oC o u r a g e o u s E=Plo r e r sp? E d u c a tio n L itig a tibba
5、 n d Ju d io ia l l,bova tio=in Ch i-n a , 20 H a r v a rd H u m an R ig ht s Jo u r n al 14 1 (20 0 7);5 ,:uE/5v,uEv20 0 7 M3bK+ M , | M5i S 7iEH E p5b , i g pt( 5) ,K E % (19 98)310|;W: g L q -, E paE?a?c?,4fb P4o E pG pf,9 V ? b PE2 M 5,Y9 V? T % bq3br qwiBq$ 4,K E BbE“d =, “ q E, , Bqi qiZE,QoEp
6、,:;q43r :u :1 u: # Yv,u1 Ev19 98 M1 b Zo:uYV %?ZE p:BE5v,wIuE Wv3 ,E p200 Mb Zo ;n -q18r, T ho m a s K e llo g gbu m M u I kT?E! n 3n? ; v,u 2 Hv2bb2 M53 b1) , Vn I:uvE v,E p2 0 0 2 M; I:u v,v20 03 Mb13 4E %5?p V ,Zf VQ 1 pb+Y ,n %sP %p,; P | sP #P,9 , . % TY , % E? HE paE?cp V 8?,5 VP+B bq4 a qEVP
7、5b 4 5:n; ? 9 HW n Sp V L ,C , ? p , i V ?;T,n %sP -, B #P, % % b$ :5 E pG ,T ) V,EAG E p %bV QV ,ZEV , h p, $ %E,i3 7v p V bE2 gh % H,i 45bE2 r % -, HW % bB Yqv Y E2 , 5A MM1b qB , gh a % T -,vE =; BQoE ,p ) b q ,E2 o V : F,$ P ) b ,5 ,Z qa f,C , ,7 P 5B f , * , P E pin, M5|$E p s,V75B f bF - y ,5
8、b+?, % /?b $Z1P in,E :onT q %, # # h ?M ,nT %p - # h,P | # h #Pin;T qpV %,V s p # hE m5?,n|N %_ rb$nT q p V -,P | #Pin;T %,9| %_ L= r,Y _1 4 # 4 P, %gbpq45rA , % s inb 3 I uK Ev BqB , %M13,Vr b5E 5) ,9 s ,A7n ,E2 7 Si M5 %bVBq q,q M , , EM, %nJM, 7,VE2+i M/B ,i M,E p?Z Blb f Iq4 5r“ ,Z4,v p, 3V %g a
9、,E p“ ?;Gvo( sP qp V %p %) , 8V YVp1 p,6 !a7 Qa3 V %T %sP b gZ uE % ,q19 99rZ310 3|.135E20 09 Ml , qB , % $wJ, )Ei 5b46rVE p ,ZEB , %1 b qil % - s1b q QV ,sYE 8: = PbB , %, q Y q# -Bq 7 Yb q %,2 uE() b,P | #Pa r ($ lb51r200 5 M3u Yn 35 ?v )s,? n 3)s1Sa saG a a)s a(5 5H) ,T)s % -,P | 3 #P(5 6H),1 )s
10、% , (58H)bn 3q4 6rq47rq48rq49rq5 0r5 IJ gB)E2 00b M430 g ,? ,b L8,7 $ 4o( V) Hr5, ,E ? bpbZEV ,E K,| b= ,E ZE , %bn gB)E ,w20 0 0rB343|; gZ uE ,w20 0 0rZ3157|; gB)E ,w2001rB35 0|b/4, :uv“$v,u Mv1 9 9 9 M1224 ;Z:uZ :S = n vp Cbn :un “| B p V 3v! s1GEn Y v,uS Mv1 9 9 9 M1223 ; -q4 3r, I ,oE ,p5b(2 )S
11、vES v S 20 0 0 M16 z 7a 1 S20 n5 5SE5 5oS n M15)pbn :u vB % EZ 7 )v,uS Mv2bbb M19 ;yoa W!:u ? Ev,u_ v2bbb M110 ;Yaf :uE I:S n M15 )?K1v,uSv20 0 0 M113 ;:uo vpE p Iv,uE v20 0 0 M116 b(3 )SE2bbb M120 SEz 7a usEVZEKE4)EE2Fo )pb :uv1 ES: E v( ) Uv,uE -v2 001 M4 ,E p2001 MbN,u S Hv20 0b M120 oB F $ : ?)
12、p5, | % v A Sv,uE pv20bb M5 b T E1b T1B/1 M - u SE()5, V A Mbnp ZEhttp : / / ww w . sks k.bo m / s ho w n ew s . a s p ? n e w sid = 154 7 ,K 20 08 M1 120 b136E %5 1u Yn 35 ?v? ,ou?v:5,?nT # 3 m5 H,AN o KaHqa HK#arlllpbq52r? , B n S/v =vntt M 8?bq53raop % Bq q 1 P ,9 V ? tE2E ,i Mb/ 1uK Ev3 #+ ,V 5
13、E LlB?Zb f g :p %,op43 nQC % ,S“B“ ?Zb 7? g lr P BVbq54rf1 b 8)Eo Y L ba1 paoQEpao pao , poL p g b ) M1 , % , g T l 7?r P , 6B , S r 7?,QEb 7, % Q E p?bRr5 Eau 8 L EvE pE?,9 ?C1|M1q r 1“ ?b ,E2BQ 50 , E2 0 b % gy ! % %,E 41E p ? f /N5bq55rBa= ,E ( ,$ % gy ! # h# Z T,S %,Q u 8 g %5 H v?b56rBH Eg %1 ,
14、E V L , )b , uE % - B :o5uS g %5 H vu 8 g %5 H v % ?,1 % H s p Y E , Y p5 #Pb % gy ! % %t H, p5 #P, llpb /,Ei : Z ,X SU 4 ; % gy ! G S %, P | #P, o pbBo5llllp, E b ,9 E b - 4 M1,EB K7 bq5 4rq55rq5 6r :u L ? v, 20 0 5 M329 ,http : / / n ew s . x in hu a n e t.bo m / z he n g fu / 20 0 5B0 3/ 29/ eo n
15、 t e n t_ 2 7 583 31 . htm ,K 20 0 8 M1120 bu S/v 3) ?( k)v,n?200 5x74|, S/v_teac h. us tb.e du. cn/ ie _ ed it/ u p -lo adfile/ 20 070 32110423025 7 . do e ;u S/v 3n = # 5 E( k)v,n? 20 0 5x7 5|, S/v_http : / / jx . u stb. edu . c n / ben ean dy. php? fid = 51_id= 4 15bK 2008 Mx l20 buK Ev2bbb M4 bu
16、K Ev20 04 M8 bu 8 g %5 H v19H?:o$ %N H, p$ % in; % $ % ?rB, %5 Hq 4 p, gg f ;f4 ,Eg gp %b g)EB , %gp %B1 ,p1 | aZTYfFp,q58r oQp, E54H?oQEpbB #p 15bpE Fd?,o # hp 8 1“ aE F, VT Fpp, ?p1Y Fpb p1Y,L k1-)( )p) ,i ? Z T( gh)pV, B5bq59rpE 8?,B Hi bq6br g)E oQEp / =db 8)E2004 M12= , % P5 bn5,= , %, F 7“bB ,
17、Z Y copp( % B ,)z, =Y4 p # h V E K,# g5 f? E,bE ,p # h # hpV E K,y7,p1 s p # hb B,E Vgp %,? ,pE,oQp 9 VVb= , 8)E B ,EB % , p # h # hp VE Kb“, L Es1 bM,= ,Eo1pp B5:o1GvpEp % H, T V ?Y m, A aZ TY FpiP |in?pQ,= , % F7 bB , %,$P :opE1 ? H , Fpp1 j f %bf Fp, ?N p1QEbpN,= , %7 s:opE ?p1AY Fp, 1 p,1T % H,P |M1 Y inllb g P |fq59rq60ruK Ev2bb5 M3 bBa= , % sYn g) E % , (20 04)321|; 8) E % , (2 0 04) 31 0|bB , % ,p
